Friday, May 18, 2012

Active vs Passive

Active RFID and Passive RFID are fundamentally different technologies that are often evaluated together. While both use radio frequency energy to communicate between a tag and a reader, the method of powering the tags is different. Active RFID uses an internal power source (battery) within the tag to continuously power the tag and its RF communication circuitry, whereas Passive RFID relies on RF energy transferred from the reader to the tag to power the tag.

Passive RFID requires stronger signals from the reader, and the signal strength returned from the tag is constrained to very low levels. Active RFID allows very low-level signals to be received by the tag (because the reader does not need to power the tag), and the tag can generate high-level signals back to the reader. Additionally, the Active RFID tag is continuously powered, whether in the reader field or not. Active tags can also 'beacon,' or initiate communication with a reader (or other tags) when certain conditions are present. Active tags can also contain external sensors to monitor temperature, humidity, motion, and other conditions.

  Active RFID Passive RFID
Power
Battery operated
No internal power
Required Signal Strength
Low
High
Communication Range
Long range (100m+)
Short range (3m)
Data Storage
Large read/write data (128kb)
Small read/write data (128b)
Per Tag Cost
Generally, $15 to $100
Generally, $0.15 to $5.00
Tag Size
Varies depending on application
"Sticker" to credit card size
Fixed Infrastructure Costs
Lower - cheaper interrogators
Higher - fixed readers
Per Asset Variable Costs
Higher - see tag cost
Lower - see tag cost
Best Area of Use
High volume assets moving within designated areas ("4 walls") in random and dynamic systems
High volume assets moving through fixed choke points in definable, uniform systems
Industries / Applications
Auto dealerships
Auto manufacturing
Hospitals - asset tracking
Construction
Mining
Laboratories
Remote monitoring
IT asset management
Supply chain
High volume manufacturing
Libraries / book stores
Pharmaceuticals
Passports
Electronic tolls
Item level tracking

Copyright 2010 by Atlas RFID Solutions, Inc.